The Fractured Path: Humayun's Vision for Kashmir Lost to Fraternal Strife

The dust had barely settled on the plains of Kanauj, where Humayun's forces suffered a crushing defeat against Sher Khan. Stripped of his Indian heartland, the Emperor faced an uncertain future. His immediate need was not just survival, but a strategic foothold from which to regroup and, perhaps, one day reclaim his lost dominion.

A Glimmer of Hope: The Kashmir Plan

Amidst the chaos, a compelling idea emerged: Kashmir. Mirza Haidar, a cousin and seasoned military man, presented a vision of the valley as a secure and resource-rich base. Its mountainous terrain offered natural defenses, making it difficult for Sher Khan's artillery-dependent army to follow. From Kashmir, Humayun could rebuild his strength, secure his family, and plan his next move away from the immediate threat of the Afghans. The prospect of this charming country, a stark contrast to the harsh realities of the plains, grew increasingly appealing to Humayun.

Brothers Divided: Conflicting Visions

However, the path to Kashmir was fraught with internal conflict. Humayun's brothers – Kamran, Hindal, and Yadgar Nasir Mirza – held their own ideas about the future, none of which aligned with the Emperor's strategic foresight. Despite the recent shared calamity, the bonds of brotherhood proved fragile. Instead of uniting behind a common goal, they offered conflicting proposals:

• Kamran Mirza: Already holding Kabul and Qandahar, Kamran suggested the Emperor and other Mirzas seek temporary refuge in the mountains while he took their families to Kabul. He promised to return later, but his underlying ambition and lack of commitment were evident.
• Hindal Mirza and Yadgar Nasir Mirza: Their proposal was to abandon India entirely for the time being and head south to Bhakkar in Sind. Their aim was to conquer Sind and then potentially Gujrat, hoping these regions would provide the resources needed for a future return to India.
• Mirza Haidar: He advocated for the Kashmir plan, offering to secure the valley with a small force while the others held the strategic mountain slopes from Sihrind to Sarang. He emphasized Kashmir's safety and the difficulty Sher Khan would face in pursuing them there.

Humayun, seeing the wisdom in Mirza Haidar's plan and drawn to the idea of a secure base, leaned towards Kashmir. Yet, the lack of consensus among his brothers was a dangerous sign.

The Bitter Taste of Treachery

The disunity quickly escalated into outright betrayal, primarily driven by Kamran Mirza. Feigning illness, Kamran refused to join Humayun's main force, instead retreating towards Kabul. Worse, he actively undermined the Emperor, secretly sending his sadr (a high-ranking official) Qazi 'Abdullah to Sher Khan to negotiate a separate peace and secure his own position in the Panjab. This act of seeking aid from the enemy against his own brother was a profound violation of loyalty and trust.

Despite Humayun's pleas for unity and offers of reconciliation, Kamran remained obstinate. He even persuaded some of Humayun's own men to accompany him to Kabul, further depleting the Emperor's already diminished force. Mirza Haidar, though initially tempted by Kamran, ultimately recognized the Emperor's just cause and remained loyal, accompanying Humayun.

Meanwhile, Hindal and Yadgar Nasir Mirza, after initially proposing the Sind route, seemed to follow Humayun towards the Indus. However, their commitment was fleeting. Instigated by disaffected elements, they too abandoned the Emperor in the desolate desert region, leaving him with a tiny, struggling band of followers, wandering without water or supplies, guided only by endurance and reliance on God.

The High Cost of Disunity

Humayun, though deeply wounded by the actions of his brothers, pressed on towards Bhakkar. The dream of Kashmir, a strategic retreat that could have changed the course of his exile, was effectively shattered by the fractured will of his family. The lack of unity, the conflicting ambitions, and the outright treachery of his brothers left Humayun vulnerable and alone, forcing him into a prolonged and arduous period of wandering and hardship.

This episode serves as a stark reminder of the critical importance of unity, especially in times of crisis. The failure of Humayun's brothers to set aside their personal interests and support the Emperor's strategic vision not only cost them their immediate advantage but also prolonged their collective suffering and significantly delayed the Mughal return to India. History, in this instance, offers a clear lesson on the destructive power of internal discord against a determined external threat.

"When Humayun finally reached Bhakkar, it was not as the leader of a united force ready to rebuild, but as a weary sovereign, abandoned by those closest to him, facing the next chapter of his exile alone."

\